BMCR 2026.11.22

The Jews of Ptolemaic Egypt: the history of a diaspora community in light of the papyri

, The Jews of Ptolemaic Egypt: the history of a diaspora community in light of the papyri. Berlin: De Gruyter, 2024. Pp. xiv, 293. ISBN 9783111425047.

Preview

 

Zsuzsanna Szántó’s book offers a wide-ranging study of the Jewish diaspora in Egypt from the conquest of Alexander the Great to the end of Ptolemaic rule in 30 BCE. The study is based on approximately 200 documentary papyri, supplemented by a smaller number of literary papyri, epigraphical material, and literary works (Josephus, Philo, the Letter of Aristeas, and 3 Maccabees). Its main goal is to reconstruct the history of the Jews of Ptolemaic Egypt primarily from everyday documents that reveal social, economic, legal, and cultural realities.

In the introduction, Szántó reviews the history of scholarship and discusses methodological issues. She points out that her work builds on the material gathered in volumes I and IV of the Corpus Papyrorum Judaicarum (which cover the Ptolemaic period). Volume IV was published in 2022, and is part of an initiative to update the (first) three volumes (1957–1964) of the Corpus Papyrorum Judaicarum edited under the leadership of Victor A. Tcherikover and mainly devoted to Greek documentary papyri. Szántó, along with Noah Hacham, Tal Ilan, Deborah Jacobs, and Meron-Martin Piotrkowski, is part of the editorial team that now also includes literary evidence and Aramaic and Demotic texts; furthermore, when selecting corpus material, stricter criteria are now applied—compared to Tcherikover’s time—in determining which documents can be definitively classified as “Jewish.”

In chapter 1, Szántó sets out the historical and geographical framework. First, she provides an overview of politically significant incidents relating to Jewish life in Ptolemaic Egypt. As for the relative scarcity of papyrological evidence from the first century, it is argued that this does not point to demographic decline, but rather to growing Hellenization, which makes Jews harder to identify in the sources. Second, from a geographical perspective, the chapter shows that Jewish settlement was widely spread across Egypt. Besides the main center in Alexandria, there were Jewish communities in the Nile Delta, Memphis, the Fayum, the Heracleopolite nome, the Oxyrhynchite nome, Thebes, and Edfu. For Alexandria, Ptolemaic papyri are largely lacking, but inscriptions and burial evidence confirm a substantial Jewish presence. In the Delta, synagogue inscriptions from Schedia, Xenephyris, Nitriai, and Athribis indicate organized communities. The location of the Onias temple at Leontopolis/Tell el-Yehudiyeh in the eastern Delta remains debated, but Szántó finds the traditional identification still plausible after weighing the archaeological and textual evidence. In the Fayum, tax registers, synagogue inscriptions, and military papyri point to a dense Jewish presence. Heracleopolis is especially significant because it yields evidence for a Jewish community organized as politeuma. In Upper Egypt, especially Thebes and Edfu, a somewhat different profile emerges: communities more deeply shaped by the Egyptian environment and in part still linked to Aramaic traditions.

Chapter 2 focuses on onomastics. Since papyri only rarely identify people explicitly as Jews, names are a main tools for recognition. Szántó shows that Jewish naming practices in Egypt were highly mixed. In Upper Egypt, the Aramaic texts from Edfu preserve older Semitic naming patterns that go back to the Persian period. At the same time, the chapter demonstrates strong Hellenization. Roughly 41%of the names borne by Jews in the papyri are Greek. Jews adopted dynastic names such as Alexander, Ptolemy, Arsinoe, and Berenice, likely as a way of signaling attachment to the ruling order of the Hellenistic kingdom. By contrast, the influence of the Hasmoneans and the Maccabean revolt on naming habits in Egypt was limited; unlike in Palestine, names like Mattathias or Judah did not become especially prominent. Greek theophoric names such as Theodoros, Theodotos, and Dositheos were common, though Szántó stresses that such names cannot automatically be treated as proof of Jewish identity, since non-Jews used them as well. The Egyptian environment also left its mark. About 8 % of the names are of Egyptian origin. This suggests that Jews and Egyptians did not live in sealed-off social worlds. In Upper Egypt especially, Egyptian names occur within Jewish families, and names often associated with Jews appear in Egyptian contexts. A particularly important case is Shabtai/Sabbataios, traditionally viewed as a distinctively Jewish name. Szántó shows, however, that it also appears in settings that are not clearly Jewish and at times seem strongly Egyptian. It therefore cannot be used as an infallible marker of Jewish identity. The chapter also discusses biblical names. Names such as Abram, Jacob, Isaac, and Joseph appear in Egypt even though they are much less common in Hellenistic Palestine. Szántó sees this as evidence for the importance of the Greek Old Testament or Septuagint in shaping the self-understanding of Egyptian Jews.

Chapter 3 examines Jews in the Ptolemaic army. In Upper Egypt, the Aramaic sources from Edfu suggest that an older military settlement survived from the Persian period, comparable to the earlier Jewish colony at Elephantine. In Middle and Lower Egypt, by contrast, Jews appear as Greek-speaking military settlers. They show up both as cleruchs, who held land in return for service, and as mercenary soldiers. The papyri attest Jews also as members of the epigone, i.e., descendants of military settlers. Szántó also discusses the categories “Macedonians” and “Persians of the epigone,” arguing that some Jews may have been counted under those labels. A central topic of this chapter is the Jewish politeuma of Heracleopolis, known from a remarkable papyrus archive (P.Polit.Iud.). Szántó interprets this institution not as an autonomous political body, but as a sociomilitary association embedded within the Ptolemaic system. It thus had religious, military, and administrative functions, was led by archons and possessed internal procedures, but it was not an independent polity in the modern sense. This reading corrects older views that treated Jewish politeumata primarily as political counterparts to Greek poleis.

Chapter 4 turns to Jews in civil society. The papyri make clear that Jews were not only soldiers; they were active in many occupations. In tax lists, they appear alongside other Greek-speaking immigrants as members of the privileged group of Hellenes. Some of them can be found among “police” or security forces as phylakitai, epistatai, and perhaps even served as strategoi. In the administration they further appear as scribes, tax collectors, and other local officials. One especially prominent figure is Dositheos son of Drimylos, who is attested as the eponymous priest of the ruler cult and is also known from literary tradition. Furthermore, Jews are also found as tax farmers, but hitherto not as bankers. In agriculture, they appear both as cultivators of royal or cleruchic land in Lower Egypt and as tenants or lessees of confiscated land in Upper Egypt. They also occur as merchants and craftsmen. The overall impression is of a minority that was deeply integrated into the economy and represented at many different social levels.

Chapter 5 addresses legal practice. Ptolemaic Egypt was characterized by legal pluralism: royal law, Greek law, Egyptian law, and possibly Jewish law in Greek translation all existed side by side. Szántó argues that the Septuagint could function, in some sense, as the (civic) law of the Jews in Egypt. Yet the papyri show that, in practice, Jews mostly used Greek legal forms. This is true of loans, sales, leases, and many other transactions. One revealing issue is interest-bearing loans. Biblical law discouraged or forbade a Jew from taking interest from another Jew, but the documentary record shows Jewish creditors and debtors operating within normal Greek contractual structures, including interest. This points to their integration into the surrounding legal world. The same is true in matters of marriage and family law. Traces of specifically Jewish practice are faint. Some texts from the politeuma refer to “ancestral law” or an “ancestral oath,” but most marriage-related documents involving Jews follow Greek or Egyptian legal conventions. This does not mean that Jewish norms were irrelevant in these arenas, but they do not seem to have been conspicuously predominant either.

Chapter 6 explores Judaism and anti-Judaism. On the side of lived religion, Szántó investigates Sabbath observance, synagogues, and communal practice. Some documentary papyri indicate that Jews refrained from work on the Sabbath. Inscriptions and papyri also attest the existence of synagogues or proseuchai in several Egyptian locations already in the Ptolemaic period. Their primary functions were likely assembly, prayer, and the study of Torah. This is especially important because Egypt provides some of the earliest secure evidence for synagogues. The second half of the chapter examines the origins of anti-Jewish discourse in Egypt. Greek and Egyptian authors such as Manetho, Lysimachus, Apion, and Chaeremon retold the Exodus story in hostile ways, presenting Jews as impure, impious, or dangerous. Szántó traces the roots of these polemics to Egyptian priestly circles. Jews, from an Egyptian perspective, could appear associated with ruling outsiders, especially since they often held privileged positions under the Ptolemies. Even so, Szántó emphasizes that there is no evidence for open hostility toward Jews under the Ptolemies. On the whole, they continued to enjoy royal support until the end of the dynasty.

Taken as a whole, the book presents a picture of a deeply integrated yet still slightly distinct diaspora community. The Jews of Egypt were neither isolated from their surroundings nor simply absorbed by them. They adopted Greek and Egyptian names, legal habits, social roles, and cultural forms, while still maintaining communal markers such as Sabbath observance, synagogue life, certain naming traditions, and collective institutions. What the papyri reveal above all is a world shaped by pragmatism, multilingualism, and cultural overlap—while taking into account the historically rooted differences between Jewish communities in Lower and Upper Egypt. Ultimately, Szántó’s study once again demonstrates that the history of the Jewish diaspora in Hellenistic Egypt is best understood not only through famous literary narratives, but through the ordinary documents of daily life.

There is no question that Szántó has produced an impressive work on a topic whose body of literature is vast and difficult to navigate. The book presents a thematic synthesis of volumes I and IV of the Corpus Papyrorum Judaicarum and provids an updated, well-developed summary overview of the subject matter; in doing so, Szántó has achieved her goal. The fact that such a synthesis cannot open up new perspectives in every respect is due to the source material and can therefore not be attributed to the author. Nevertheless, leaving aside the chapter on onomastics, which is undoubtedly one of the book’s strengths, one would have liked to see a greater effort to go beyond what is already known from literature. A thematic focus could have been established, for example, in connection with the thesis that the Jewish communities in Upper Egypt, above all the one in Edfu, were closely connected to their Egyptian surroundings; this perspective is not new, but it still deserves attention and could have been expanded upon by Szántó—even setting aside the detailed discussion of the name Shabtai (pp. 80–88, 238). Furthermore, is it possible to conclude from the use of “names of biblical heroes” that “not all Jews were Hellenized or Egyptianized” (p. 238)?

At least one further issue must be noted from a bibliographic perspective: I am surprised that my book on the institution of the politeuma (Die ptolemäische Organisationsform politeuma. Ein Herrschaftsinstrument zugunsten jüdischer und anderer hellenischer Gemeinschaften. Texts and Studies in Ancient Judaism, 178. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck 2019) was not included (especially since Szántó devoted a subchapter [3.3; pp. 122–141] to this institution). Furthermore, the author might have made further use of Robert Kugler’s 2022 monograph (Resolving disputes in second century BCE Herakleopolis: a study in Jewish legal reasoning in Hellenistic Egypt. Supplements to the Journal for the Study of Judaism, 201. Leiden: Brill), which is cited only once, in the chapter on “Jews in the Ptolemaic Army.”

The book is to be wished a wide readership—and this wish will undoubtedly come true, for at present there is no other current introduction to the subject of Judaism in Ptolemaic Egypt.