Many accounts of the transition from the Bronze Age to the Iron Age around 1200 BC, portray it as a period of widespread upheaval and destruction caused by the arrival of the so-called “Sea Peoples,” alongside natural disasters. The turmoil, according to this view, affected a vast region, including the Aegean, Turkey, Cyprus, the Levant, and Egypt, and led to the collapse of major states and empires, such as the Mycenaean palace states and the kingdom of Ugarit.
Here, the historian and archaeologist Jesse Millek boldly challenges an idea that has shaped scholarship for over 150 years. Chapter 1 provides a historical overview), focusing on the very concept of “destruction”.
In Chapter 2, “The Archaeology of Destruction: Denoting, Describing and Classifying”, Millek points out how subjective the concept of destruction often is in academic literature. He compares varied interpretations, using perspectives from related fields, such as ceramic typology, particularly in the Aegean.
But what exactly is “destruction”? What specifically defines a building as having been “destroyed”? Millek draws on a definition by Israel Finkelstein[1], who identifies destruction as the presence of at least two of three key features: a burned layer, significant structural collapse onto the floor, and broken objects found in situ on the floor. Millek further emphasizes that such evidence found in just one or two rooms does not necessarily indicate the destruction of the entire building.
The second issue Millek addresses is the scale of destruction, which he separates into four levels: partial destruction; destruction of a single building; multiple buildings; or an entire site. The third focus is on the cause of destruction, which may be unknown, natural (such as earthquakes), accidental, or intentional. Millek calls for what he terms a true “archaeology of destruction” that takes into account all these factors.[2]
In the following chapter, “The Destruction That Wasn’t”, Millek argues that of the 153 sites commonly believed to have been destroyed in around 1200 BCE, 94 of them, about 61%, are “false destructions.” These include sites where the destruction layers are poorly dated, limited to small portions of the site, or entirely absent but destruction is assumed based on theoretical models. Often the initial presupposition was perpetuated by a “citation chain” where an initial, weak attribution was repeatedly cited without critical reassessment (pp. 54–55). Through a series of case studies, such as Orchomenos, Phaistos, Alaca Höyük and Carchemish, Millek shows that in regions like the central Levant or the Cyclades, no destruction occurred around 1200 BCE, despite claims in earlier literature. In other areas, such as the rest of the Levant, Crete and Cyprus, 60–70% of reported destructions fall into his “false” category. In Greece and Anatolia this percentage drops to 45-46%. Overall, Millek concludes that many of the so-called destructions of the Late Bronze Age were relatively minor events. More than half of the cases cited in prominent works, including those by Robert Drews and Eric Cline[3], turn out to be either exaggerated or disproved by more recent research.
The following chapters offer a detailed analysis of the destructions reported in the literature, drawing on the latest excavation data, in some cases supported by site plans and charts.
In Chapter 4, “Destruction in Mycenaean Greece and the Wider Aegean,” Millek examines the Aegean region. Aside from evidence of warfare or fire at Midea, Pylos, and Tiryns (with the situation at Mycenae noted as less clear), he finds virtually no credible evidence of destruction in Crete or the Cyclades. Where destruction did occur, it mostly affected public buildings. Millek argues that these destruction events do not appear to have directly caused the collapse of the Mycenaean system. Nor do they seem to have happened within a narrow timeframe. As he puts it, “The fact that many, though not all, of the monumental structures and palaces were destroyed is more than likely a symptom rather than a cause in the abandonment of the palatial system” (p. 169).
In Chapter 5, “Destruction in Anatolia and the Fall of the Hittite Empire”, Millek examines key sites across Anatolia. At the most renowned site, Troy, the destruction layer dated to around 1230–1190/1180 BCE, Level VIIa, is clearly the result of a major conflict, supported by evidence such as weapons, skeletons, and widespread fire damage. At Hattusa, the Hittite capital, signs of violent destruction by fire are visible in several public buildings. However, these structures appear to have been deliberately emptied before being burned, while other parts of the site were simply abandoned. Millek suggests that internal unrest, rather than external invasion, likely led to the city’s collapse, and that Hattusa may have already been deserted before the fires occurred. At other sites in Anatolia, the evidence is either inconclusive or not securely dated to the period around 1200 BCE. Overall, Millek finds no convincing link between the fall of the Hittite Empire, which had already been in decline for some time, and the supposed wave of destructions. Theories involving earthquakes or invasions by Sea Peoples are, in his view, unconvincing.
In Chapter 6, “Cyprus and the Absence of Destruction at the End of the Late Bronze Age”, Millek engages with the ongoing debate over whether Cyprus experienced widespread destruction around 1200 BCE. He finds few cases that he considers genuine. His analysis reveals a largely peaceful transition on the island between the 13th and 12th centuries, accompanied by signs of growth and prosperity, paralleling similar developments in Crete and parts of the Levant.
Chapter 7, “The Levant: A Mixed Bag of Destruction”, addresses the Near East. Among many “false” cases, Millek recognizes 28 legitimate destructions across the northern and southern Levant, though none in the central region. Various causes have been proposed for these events, including Sea Peoples, Canaanites, Egyptians and earthquakes. However, Millek contends that destruction played only a minor role in the broader collapse around 1200 BCE.
The best-known site in the northern Levant is Ras Shamra, the capital of the Ugaritic kingdom, where the destruction was clearly the result of armed conflict. Arrowheads found there are second in number only to those at Pylos. In the same region, other sites show signs of destruction either from unknown causes or from fire. In the southern Levant, most sites with destruction layers, including Megiddo, are attributed by Millek to unknown causes. One exception is Aphek, where evidence points to a violent assault. At Lachish, Millek suggests a different scenario: a voluntary or controlled destruction, supported by signs of continued architectural activity after 1200 BCE. On some sites, in Cyprus for example, there is evidence at a few locations of a “squatter” phase, or temporary reoccupation, following the initial destruction.
So what caused the only 28 genuine destructions Millek identifies across this broad region? First, he rules out a widespread wave of earthquakes during this period, a theory still supported by some scholars but not backed by evidence. The most widely accepted explanation remains the famous Sea Peoples, but Millek challenges this too. He notes that Egyptian texts make no clear reference to destructions in Anatolia, Cyprus, or the Levant, except for the Levantine centre of Amurru, whose location is still uncertain. In fact, the Egyptian records speak of how the pharaohs defeated the Sea Peoples. As for Ugaritic and Hittite sources, these refer generally to repeated incursions by various groups, but do not specifically mention the Sea Peoples.
All of this fits in well with the archaeological evidence. At most, one might attribute some destructions at Transjordanian sites to Canaanite activity. According to Millek, there is only one site where the involvement of the Sea Peoples seems plausible: Tell Kazel, which may be the Amurru mentioned in the texts. The commonly held idea that Egyptian rule collapsed immediately due to these “destructions” is also, in Millek’s view, unsupported by the evidence. Regarding the potential impact on trade networks, Millek draws on archaeometallurgical studies[4] to show that the use of tin continued uninterrupted, even after the destruction of Ugarit. He also notes that imports from Cyprus and Mycenaean Greece into the southern Levant had already declined well before 1200 BCE[5]. Millek also shows that many sites labeled as “destroyed” actually continued to be occupied afterward. He further addresses the theory of prolonged periods of arid climate between the Late Bronze Age and Early Iron Age. As he writes, “…the destructions that preceded these events were only the capstone on a long period of political turmoil, and the destruction was not the de facto cause for the abandonments” (p. 270).
In his conclusion (Chapter 8: “Overview and Impact on Mediterranean Societies”), Millek summarizes the archaeological data: of the 59 “genuine” destructions he identifies, 17 were partial, and 19 involved only a single building at a site. In other words, 61% of these events caused only limited damage. That leaves just 23 cases where multiple buildings or entire sites were destroyed. Yet even these, Millek argues, had no significant impact on the broader societies of the time. In many of the regions he examines, such destructions either did not occur or were only minor. Some sites were indeed abandoned, but many others, including some arguments for collapse, flourished in the post-Bronze Age period.
The situation in mainland Greece and the northern Levant stands apart. In Greece, while some cases of destruction remain uncertain, there are clear examples of war-related damage or arson, though these may have occurred at different moments during LH IIIC. Millek follows Joseph Maran[6], who suggests that these destructions were not more decisive in the collapse of the Mycenaean world than other contributing factors. A similar argument applies to Syrian sites such as Ras Shamra. Millek proposes that in many instances, sites were not rebuilt simply because they had already been largely abandoned by the time destruction occurred. He also critiques several dominant theories: the notion of widespread earthquakes around 1200 BCE (questioning both the scale and dating), the idea of devastation by the mysterious Sea Peoples or raiders, the theory of climate change causing famine (noting that food remains are still found in abandoned sites) and the claim that the trade ports had collapsed. Ultimately, Millek suggests that the idea of a vast, interconnected crisis is likely a modern projection, influenced by today’s globalised perspective, rather than a reflection of actual conditions in the Late Bronze Age. This brings Millek to two key conclusions:
- Similar episodes of collapse, warfare and upheaval occurred in earlier periods and were no less violent than those around 1200 BCE.
- The notion that this particular period saw an exceptional level of destruction is not grounded in solid evidence, but rather stems from a long-standing hypothesis.
In other words, we cannot claim that a specific region or time was marked by increased destruction without a systematic comparison of the number and nature of destructive events before and after that period. Only by examining destruction across all periods and regions can we begin to understand its true impact on ancient societies.
In conclusion, Millek’s book offers a thought-provoking, if certainly debatable, perspective on one of the most enduring questions in ancient history. One can only hope it will serve as a catalyst for renewed scholarly debate.
Notes
[1] I. Finkelstein, “Destructions: Megiddo as a Case Study”, in J. David Schloen, W.Lake eds., Exploring the Longue Durée: Essays in Honor of Lawrence E. Stager, Eisenbrauns, Pennsylvania State University (2009), pp. 113-126.
[2] A surprising omission, from this point of view, are Pompeii and Thera, arguably the most famous archaeological examples of destruction caused by natural disasters. Neither site is discussed in the text or listed in the site index.
[3] See, for example, R. Drews, The End of the Bronze Age: Changes in Warfare and the Catastrophe ca. 1200 BC, Princeton: Princeton University Press (1993); Idem, “Catastrophe Revisited”, in G. D. Middleton ed., Collapse and Transformations: The Late Bronze Age to the Early Iron Age. Oxford, Oxbow (2020), pp. 229-235; E. H. Cline, 1177 BC; The Year Civilization Collapsed, Princeton, Princeton University Press (2021).
[4] N. Yahalom-Mack N., A. Eliyahu.Behar, “The transition from Bronze to Iron in Canaan: Chronology, Technology and Context”, Radiocarbon 57 (2015): 285-305.
[5] P.W.Stochammer, “How Aegean is Philistine Pottery? The Use of Aegean Type Pottery in the Early 12th Century BCE Southern Levant” in P. M.Fischer, T. Bürge eds., “Sea Peoples” up-to-date. New Research on Transformations in the Eastern Mediterranean in the 13th–11th Centuries BCE, Wien, Österreichische Academie der Wissenschaften (2017): 379-388.
[6] J. Maran, “Tiryns and the Argolid in Mycenean Times: New Clues and Interpretations”, in A.L. Schallin, I. Tournavitou eds., Mycenaeans Up to Date. The archaeology of the northeastern Peloponnese―current concepts and new directions, Skrifter Utgivna Av Svenska Institutet I Athen, Stockholm, (2015): 277-293.