The anatomical ex-votos of Republican Italy are a rather poignant class of offerings. They are a window into the everyday religious practices of the inhabitants of Roman Italy, documenting their requests to the gods for healing, protection and fertility. Fabiana Fabbri’s book, translated from the 2019 Italian version with some updates about the latest finds, is an up-to-date English-language overview of the class, which complements Jessica Hughes’ 2017 book Votive Body Parts in Greek and Roman Religion and the same year’s collective Bodies of Evidence.[1] More recent still is Massimiliano Papini’s detailed contribution to The Oxford Handbook of Pre-Roman Italy (2024).[2] Bearing witness to this current surge of interest in these offerings, Fabbri’s book promises to be a useful point of reference for archaeologists and scholars of ancient religious and votive practices.
The book functions well as an introduction to the topic, clearly outlining the votives and the types thereof, and their immediate and wider contexts: the votive deposits and sanctuaries where they were found and the socio-economic framework these operated within. The reader is also introduced to the existing scholarship surrounding this type of offering and the various hypotheses each entire class or particular type has elicited over the years. The main criticism that can be made of this otherwise well-documented and clear work is that having listed various ideas and hypotheses, Fabbri often fails to offer her own opinion or conclusions. This leaves many sections somewhat lacking, if not of a definitive conclusion, then at least of a weighing of the relative merits of the divergent interpretations put forward in the past. The following review will focus on occasions where that is the case.
After a short introduction, Chapter 1 provides a general framework for the topic. The anatomical ex-votos under study were offered mainly in present-day Tuscany, Lazio and parts of Campania and Molise from the early 4th century BCE onward. They were long considered a marker of Roman colonisation in the middle and late Republican periods, but recent studies have suggested other routes and reasons for their spread. Despite a small number of offerings shaped like body-parts in some Greek sanctuaries, the anatomical votives constitute a coherent and well-delimited tradition native to Etruscan and Roman Italy, with a shared iconography. The corpus comprises individual terracotta body parts and organs, torsos and heads; for this study, Fabbri comes down on the side of including heads and half-heads among the anatomical votives. Epigraphical evidence is sparse but supports the identification as ex-votos, i.e. objects that the devotee promised to the deity when asking for a favour and gave once it was granted. The objects were produced serially using moulds and matrices from a terracotta prototype and sometimes painted; all in all, these were relatively inexpensive offerings.
The first examples were found in the 17th century and were long disregarded because of their perceived low artistic value. Many more were unearthed in the 19th and early 20th centuries, and they continued to be widely dispersed throughout Europe on the antiquities market. Physicians collected them, their interest based on the evidence they believed they could gather about ancient medical practices. Based upon identical data, the objects were either understood to denote advanced practices, especially in Etruria (Pierre Découflé), or derided as entirely lacking in anatomical knowledge (Piero Giacosa, Tommasi Crudeli); this question remains a matter of inquiry.
Chapter 2 examines the origin of anatomical ex-votos, contextualizing them among the historical, social and economic developments of mid-Republican Italy. Fabbri accepts the communis opinio that they originated around Veii and Falerii in the 5th century BCE from the practice of offering heads representing the devotee to deities such as Ceres. This was an adaptation of a practice of votive masks and busts within the chthonic cults of Sicily and Magna Graecia. Fabbri frames the spread of such practices within the common interests and practices of the plebeian social class of the Middle Republic, who experienced significant economic, political and social advancement, and whose subordination to the elites was reduced. Fabbri offers a well-written and well-documented overview of the social history of Italy in this period. The terracotta ex-votos also show body parts according to the stylistic conventions of their time, such as the physiognomic portraiture of the late 4th century BCE.
In chapter 3, Fabbri provides a typology of the ex-votos, sorted by the body part represented. Lists of attestations are given for each, but the lack of concrete numbers means that it is often difficult to gauge how common or rare each type is. Heads are shown with or without veils: Fabbri’s data supports the usual theory that this reflects a distinction between religious rites. Veiled heads are capite velato, i.e. the Roman mode of sacrifice, while unveiled heads reflect Etruscan and Greek practices. Heads can also be partial, i.e., half-heads or masks. The latter may be abbreviated versions of the offerer or have a more specific meaning to do with the eyes, be it a request for healing of that body part or a metaphorical reference to the “prophylactic eye”; similarly for eyes themselves. This pattern is true of most body parts, which could either be references to an ailment affecting that area, or have some metaphorical meaning. The uterus, the most closely studied of the body parts (both in the literature and in Fabbri’s chapter), probably reflects requests for fertility and the good outcome of a pregnancy. Polyvisceral votives, which show several organs either inside a torso or outside it on a plaque, are taken to have signified internal ailments, difficult to localize precisely; according to Fabbri, the most common is malaria, which was endemic in the regions where this kind of votive is more typically found. Fabbri non-committally follows the interpretation that the enigmatic cippetti, small cones often with a flared base, probably represent hearts. Fabbri finishes with the mention of signs of disease on the body parts offered, which are surprisingly rare. This was probably because the ex-votos were purchased ready-made, which also explains the very small number of inscriptions, though some were perhaps painted. Most of the extant inscriptions mention the name of the dedicant, not the deity.
Chapters 4 and 5 offer overviews of other votive gifts that often accompany the anatomical ex-votos in deposits, again sorted by type with mentions of attestations. Among the first, we have swaddled babies, which Fabbri considers relate to fertility cults. Many wear bullae, necklaces which indicate their belonging to families of free men and their prepubescent status. Seated and crouching children are mainly an Etruscan phenomenon and have been subject to various interpretations; Fabbri cursorily hints they may be related to mantological or oracular practices. Statues of kourophoroi reflect the request for protection of maternity and the family. Finally, there are many terracotta miniature animals, alongside partial animals and even animal limbs. Fabbri rejects the hypothesis that these function as replacements for animal sacrifice or commemoration of the same, preferring to view them alongside anatomical ex-votos as requests for protection, fertility and healing of flocks. Bronze votives, with a higher economic value than terracotta, are hypothesized to have been of a precise weight, with a function analogous to that of monetary offering.
Chapter 6 departs from the overview methodology and constitutes an “in-depth study” of the link between anatomical terracotta votives and water cults in Etruria. It starts with an overview of the ways water was involved in many rituals in Antiquity, probably related to its sanitizing properties and fertilizing power. Anatomical votives are often found at such sites, although a previously accepted link between eyes or masks and water is disproven. Based on the cross-referencing of names given for discovery sites and geological data, a link is posited to locations with thermal and mineral springs.
Chapter 7 studies the deities targeted by votive anatomical offerings, with one section per deity. In an introductory section Fabbri correctly acknowledges that identifying the deity concerned by any votive deposit in Roman Italy is often difficult, if not impossible, due to the “degree of indeterminacy” of many contexts. Many female deities in particular are responsible for the same areas such as fertility, human health, the fields, childbirth and children’s growth. Following Marcel Le Glay, Fabbri attributes this to all sharing an original aspect of the Earth-Mother characteristic of archaic Mediterranean cults. Fabbri admirably teases out the subtle differences between the deities mentioned. Unfortunately, no significant correlations can be identified between particular types of anatomical votives and any specific deity: the chapter offers a general presentation of these divine personalities rather than any specific link to anatomical votives.
In chapter 8 we discover “the exceptions to the rule”: anatomical ex-votos found from beyond the geographical or chronological bounds of Republican Italy. A set of terracotta votives from the late second century and the first century BCE found in Berenice in Cyrenaica is attributed to the establishment of a community of Italians in the area. Anatomical votives attributed to Romanization have also been found in Gaul from the early first century CE, after the phenomenon had declined in Rome. The common gifting of wooden sculptures in Gaul may indicate that such a practice was widespread also in Italy where the preservation conditions have limited our direct knowledge of it.
Chapter 9, titled “A summary of new research perspectives” functions as a conclusion. Fabbri emphasizes that the importance of anatomical votives in studying the religious practices of the popular classes in Italy at that time, which has otherwise escaped the attention of scholars focused on official cults. While they have much to teach us about the “social, economic, psychological and cultic changes that occurred in Etruria and central Italy during the middle and late Republican periods”, there are few links with actual pathology and so offer less in the study of ancient medicine.
Notes
[1] J. Hughes, Votive Body Parts in Greek and Roman Religion, Cambridge, 2017 ; J. Draycott, E.-J. Graham (ed.), Bodies of Evidence. Ancient Anatomical Votives Past, Present and Future, Abingdon, 2017 (Medicine and the Body in Antiquity).
[2] M. Papini, “Bodies in Pieces in Central Italy. Votives”, in M. Maiuro, J. Botsford Johnson (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Pre-Roman Italy (1000-49 BCE), Oxford, 2024 (Oxford Handbooks), p. 822-837.