BMCR 2026.11.19

Corpus vasorum antiquorum. U.S.A., 41. Princeton University Art Museum, 1

, , , Corpus vasorum antiquorum. U.S.A., 41. Princeton University Art Museum, 1. Athenian red-figure amphorae, loutrophoroi, pelikai, dinos, kraters, hydriai, oinochoai, askoi, pyxis, lekanis. Princeton: Princeton University Art Museum, 2025. Pp. 143. ISBN 9780943012568.

Open access

 

As the title suggests, this first Princeton University Art Museum CVA includes only 44 of the Attic red-figure vases in the museum’s collection, of which 13 are mere fragments. It excludes cups and oil vessels, which double the number and which will one hopes soon appear in a future fascicule. All the entries on the complete vases have extensive discussion of shape, style and iconography with ample comparanda and bibliography.

Princeton acquired its first Greek vases in 1890, and the collection has been amplified since primarily by donations from alumni, dealers and friends. The four successive curators since 1946 (Frances F. Jones, J. Robert Guy and J. Michael Padgett) have augmented the collection with some purchases over the last 75 years, and (with the exception of Guy) have published notices about the vases in the Record of the Art Museum, founded by the first curator Gladys Davidson Weinberg in 1942.

An early gift of note is the kalpis attributed to the Niobid Painter that depicts a simple 3-figure libation scene. It was bequeathed in 1932 by Junius S. Morgan II, who was the nephew of and advisor to J. Pierpont Morgan. While at Princeton he met Belle da Costa Greene who famously became J. P. Morgan’s chief advisor and the librarian of the Morgan Library in New York. Another vase with an aristocratic lineage is a Nolan amphora attributed to a follower of the Berlin Painter which once belonged to Cornelius Vanderbilt II and was displayed in the library of his summer “cottage” in Newport, the Breakers. A pair of mid-5th century column kraters said to have been found at Nola were donations from William Cowper Prime (class of 1843 and founder of the department of art history) in 1890, the first gifts to the museum. I mention here the background of these Princeton alumni (not mentioned in the CVA) to demonstrate the importance of antiquity collecting to the formation of one of America’s finest and largest university art museums. As Padgett has noted in his discussion of the early history of the art museum: “An appreciation of classical art was a hallmark of good taste, and a knowledge of its historical development and manifold components was a prerequisite for understanding the subsequent evolution of Western art.”[1]

Other examples of earlier acquisitions are two mid-5th-century askoi, a shape that typically depicts creatures in confrontation on the shoulder. Here, one depicts a lion roaring at a large boar, and on the other are two sirens. Although askoi are often cited as accoutrements for pouring libations at the grave, the authors argue that they more likely contained oil for domestic use (cat. 40, p.100). Two miniature late 5th-century choes illustrate, as is common, the lives of children: a crawling infant on a chous 7.5 cm. tall, and two young boys playing with a roller toy on a slightly larger one (14.4 cm. tall). This may be the only class of Attic vases where the figures dictate the scale of the container. Choes demonstrate the ancient Athenians’ acute observation of the stages of childhood, not present in most other ancient cultures.

The majority of acquisitions postdate the UNESCO agreement of 1970, and have no provenance, other than their dealers or donors (who are cited).[2] One of the more notorious is the Princeton alumnus and antiquities dealer Edoardo Almagià, awaiting extradition from Italy. As of August 2025 the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office had executed 37 seizures of 295 objects trafficked by Almagià, collectively valued at more than $6 million.[3] Four sherds that formerly belonged to the museum (Beazley Archive Pottery Database [BAPD] 29570) were from an important calyx krater attributed to Euphronios. The sherds were acquired with no known find spot by the museum in 1997, presumably from Almagià.[4] They have subsequently been returned to Italy along with many other unprovenanced antiquities.[5]

While the majority of Dietrich von Bothmer’s vast collection (16,000 pot sherds) was bequeathed to the Metropolitan Museum, where he was curator of Greek and Roman art, he also donated unprovenanced pieces to the Princeton museum.[6] Along with two unattributed sherds (a 4th-century lekanis lid fragment and a late 5th-century kalpis fragment with foliage), more interesting iconographically is a calyx-krater wall fragment preserving the feet of a draped flying woman, presumably Nike. It is attributed to the Berlin Painter, and was published for the first time in Padgett’s comprehensive exhibition catalogue devoted to this impressive artist.[7] It bears an inscription EKTOR to the left and below the Nike who hovers to the right. Nike is possibly crowning the victor Achilles although it would be unusual for the victim to be at the left as opposed to the right of his vanquisher. Another Princeton vase that appears in this catalogue is a lacunose Panathenaic-shaped amphora depicting Herakles and Hermes, one on either side in a format typical of the Berlin Painter (cat. no. 102). The barbitos- and kantharos-bearing Herakles is remarkably similar to the satyr on the reverse of the Berlin Painter’s name-vase in the Berlin Antikensammlung. However, in spite of some anomalies, this amphora was attributed by Guy to another famous vase painter, the Pan Painter, who may have learned his craft in the Berlin Painter’s workshop.

Emily Vermeule and Cornelius Vermeule, another former curator of classical antiquities (at the Boston Museum of Fine Arts), donated half a dozen red-figure sherds, all without provenance. These include a Nolan amphora depicting a libating Dionysos and a nearly complete calyx-krater attributed to the Phiale Painter depicting an unusual Dionysian gigantomachy with satyrs harnessed to bigas. Two loutrophoros fragments donated by the Vermeules in 2002 that depict women are said to be from the important Sanctuary of the Nymphs on the south slope of the Athenian Acropolis.. Because most similar sherds from this sanctuary bought by the Vermeules in the late 1950s or early 1960s on behalf of the Boston MFA were returned to Greece, one wonders why these remain in the US (p. 14). The most intriguing fragments donated by the Vermeules come from a krater attributed to the Kleophrades Painter depicting a large grave mound bedecked with armor, certainly that of Achilles. The Carlos Museum of Emory University owns 36 unpublished fragments of this vase, some of which join the Princeton sherds; a helpful montage of the relevant pieces is illustrated (pl. 25), and one can only hope that they may be joined physically in the future.[8]

Another small ex-Vermeule fragment shows Menelaus next to a flying Eros. This subject, the reclamation of Helen, appears in greater expanse on a fragmentary footed dinos (no. 12). The preserved participants include a Greek warrior, Menelaus with drawn sword, Helen rushing away, Aphrodite, and a Trojan woman. These figures suggest that other episodes from the fall of Troy may have decorated the lost sections of this large bowl. The partially preserved lid depicts the Kaineus episode of the centauromachy. A dinos with a foot and its lid is highly unusual, and equally intriguing are the attributions by Guy of the lid to the Syriskos Painter and the bowl to the Copenhagen Painter. The text includes a long discussion of the workshop relationship of these two closely related artists.

Finally, mention should be made of an intact column krater acquired from the New York art market and attributed to the Suessula Painter by Padgett. Its dynamic composition shows a galloping quadriga led and driven by figures in Thracian garb. The authors identify the bearded ‘barbarian’ as Pelops who was said to be Phrygian with his charioteer Killas, and speculate that some pro-Spartan Athenian under the Thirty Tyrants commissioned the vase.

As is now mostly the norm in CVAs, all vases are illustrated in color and shown in four profile views. These are augmented by profile drawings, an index of attributions, and a long alphabetic list of subjects from Achilles to wreath. This CVA also exists as an open-access publication with zoomable images. A visit to the Princeton Art museum (June 2026) revealed that few of the vases are on exhibit, with the majority being stored off site. However, the new display designed and implemented by the current curator Carolyn Leferrière is creatively presented with thoughtful juxtapositions. One hopes for future CVAs of this quality and scholarship from an institution that ranks among its Greek ceramic artists the black-figure Princeton Painter (coined by J.D. Beazley).

 

Notes

[1] J. Michael Padgett, “The Collection of Ancient Art: The Early Years,” Record of the Art Museum, Princeton University 55 (1996) 107.

[2] Princeton now uses 1970 as a cutoff for acquisitions of unprovenanced antiquities.

[3] “D.A. Bragg Announces Return Of Antiquities To Spain, Italy And Hungary,” August 6, 2025.

[4] See J. Michael Padgett, “Achilles and Ajax on a Calyx Krater by Euphronios,” Record of the Art Museum, Princeton University 60 (2001) 2-17.

[5] In this context mention might be made of the much publicized red-figure psykter attributed by Guy to the Kleophrades Painter which the Princeton museum acquired in 1989 (BAPD 28180) and which as of 2007 is in the Villa Giulia. See “Princeton University Art Museum and Italy to sign agreement over antiquities” (October 26, 2007). The most notorious and much criticized instance of sherd collecting on the part of a university museum is the purchase by Harvard’s Sackler museum of 182 Greek vase fragments in 1995 from the collection of J. Robert Guy, former curator at Princeton. See Aaron Paul, “Fragments of Antiquity: Drawing upon Greek Vases,” Harvard University Art Museums Bulletin 5 (Spring, 1997); for the provenance see “The Art of Ownership” John Harvard’s Journal (1998).

[6] See The Dietrich von Bothmer Fragment Collection.

[7] See J. Michael Padgett et al., The Berlin Painter and His World (Princeton 2017) 264.

[8] For further information on the provenances of these fragments see David Gill, “Bothmer, Almagià and the Michael C. Carlos Museum” Looting Matters, 21 September 2023.