BMCR 2026.11.16

Divining disaster: signs of catastrophe in ancient Greek culture

, Divining disaster: signs of catastrophe in ancient Greek culture. Mnemosyne, 496. Leiden: Brill, 2025. Pp. xii, 421. ISBN 9789004738560.

Preview

 

This volume by Michiel Van Veldhuizen is a fascinating and fresh approach to examining disasters in antiquity. While grounding his analysis within contemporary theoretical paradigms associated with the study of disasters in the social sciences, Van Veldhuizen focuses on how ancient Greek populations assigned meaning to disasters they faced. A key element of this analysis is the consideration of disasters as signs rather than events. This situates Van Veldhuizen’s research very nicely within broader disaster studies where, increasingly, disasters are not considered to be discrete events, but instead are viewed as socially-constructed processes. Such an approach provides a foundation for interpreting ancient Greek divination of disasters and considering the broader implications of this research within the context of disaster studies.

Following the introductory chapter where the theoretical basis and goals of the book are outlined, Van Veldhuizen divides the volume into five parts, each consisting of several chapters related to a broader theme. Part 1 (Divination and Semiotics) includes chapters 1–4. Each part has a brief introduction section, with the chapters following. Chapter 1 (Ancient Divination) defines how divination is considered within the book and looks at ancient Greek perspectives on this practice. The use of case studies is an important part of Van Veldhuizen’s work and he opens this chapter with Herodotus’ (6.27) account of two ‘accidents’ that preceded a major defeat of the Chian navy. This shows an overarching viewpoint, common in Herodotus, that disasters are preceded by signs, and that these signs are in some cases recognized (or discovered) only after the fact. The second chapter (Classifying the Sign) uses a grounding in semiotics to consider what makes up a sign within the context of divining disasters. Chapter 3 (Naming the Sign) takes this a step further by examining sign terminology in ancient Greek. Several terms outlined in the 12th-century Chiliades by John Tzetzes (7.152) form the basis of this analysis: teras (τέρας), sēmeion (σημεῖον), tekmērion (τεκμήριον), sumbolon (σύμβολον), and eikos (εἰκός). Chapter 4 (Abductive Reasoning) builds on these previous discussions to discuss how a sign becomes a divinatory sign. The use of abductive reasoning (where understanding the result can lead back to the origin or cause) serves as a mechanism for assessing ancient Greek perspectives on seeking causes from the effects.

Part 2 (Disasters and Definitions), which comprises Chapters 5–7, moves from the process of divining to focus on disasters themselves and the complexity of defining them in ancient and modern contexts. Chapter 5 (Three Modes of Disaster: Plutarch, Shakespeare, Derrida) includes a typology of disasters based on three constructs: disaster-as-sign, disaster-as-event, disaster-as-condition. The thread connecting this typology is that each category represents a rupture or violation of the norm, bringing about the need to understand how and why this happened. Chapter 6 (Translating Ancient Disaster) looks at the origins of the word disaster in contemporary European languages, tracing the influence of translation of works by Plutarch in bringing this term into modern vernacular, which is a research focus not seen in previous studies. The chapter then considers how perspectives of ancient disasters were influential in shaping modern constructs and understanding. In Chapter 7 (Staging Disaster in Tragedy and History), Van Veldhuizen looks at the role of disasters in different forms of writing as essential to memory. Disasters-as-signs become a common outcome in ancient and modern discussions as meaning is assigned and recovery is underway.

Part 3 (Agency and Punishment) looks at coping mechanisms following disasters across three chapters (8–10). The destruction of the city of Helike in northern Peloponnese as the result of an earthquake and tsunami in 373 BCE serves as a case study throughout this section. Chapter 8 (The Sunken City of Helike) both tells the story of the city’s destruction and also calls back to the previous two parts to consider how meaning is constructed around such a catastrophe. This includes looking at the account of an Italian traveler, Saverio Scofani, who claims to have seen the ruins of Helike in 1799 and was overwhelmed by the magnitude of its destruction. Chapter 9 (Moral Agency and Punitive Disaster) examines a central human response to disasters where the agency/cause behind them must be determined. Divine anger and punishment are often cited, which helps place the potential wrath imposed by Poseidon on Helike into a broader context. In Chapter 10 (Poseidon’s Disaster Agency) Van Veldhuizen uses the god’s anger as means to consider the cultural construction of disasters and the ways in which agency behind catastrophe is considered.

The discussion continues into Part 4 (Uncertainty and Suffering), where the focus shifts to the disorienting nature of disasters. Four chapters (11–14) make up this section of the book. Chapter 11 (Imagining Disaster aboard the Poseidon) takes a very different approach by examining the visual construction of disaster experience through analysis of the 1972 movie The Poseidon Adventure. The disorientation of survivors navigating through a ship tipped upside down offers a way to consider how signs are re-oriented in the face of disaster. Chapter 12 (The Disaster Geography of the Argonauts) looks further at being displaced and having a geographical sense of place violated by a disaster. The travails of Jason and the Argonauts, including the stranding of their ship, the Argo, in the deserts of Libya provides the basis for the discussion. In Chapter 13 (Negative Cosmology: Titans, Typhoeus, and Tartarus), Van Veldhuizen considers how disasters can impose a fear of return to a chaotic, empty state, tied to these ideas of disorientation and disruption. The final chapter of this part (14, Bound and Adrift: Prometheus, Io, and the Island of Delos) focuses on conditions of being immobilized or being adrift and the factors that can lead to reorientation.

Part 5 (Vulnerability and Contagion), consisting of Chapters 15–16, returns more overtly to the concept of divining disasters by assessing Greek attempts to make sense of plague. Chapter 15 (The Plague as Semiotic Monster) looks at ancient and modern plagues by contextualizing them within the framework of being ‘protean’, where they can shapeshift symptoms, resist categorization, and bring about a strong need to understand cause and remedy. Van Veldhuizen also examines the construct where plague is regularly tied together with famine and war in ancient (and more modern) discourse. Chapter 16 (Oracles and Plagues in Historical Narrative) provides a careful reading of several authors, Herodotus, Josephus, and Thucydides, showing a blurred spectrum of treating plague as disaster-as-sign and disaster-as-event. The book ends with a short concluding chapter that considers the phenomenological impact of writing this volume during the COVID-19 pandemic and the broader conclusions of human tendency to associate signs with disasters.

This book, overall, is a commendable effort to approach disaster studies from a novel and important perspective. The focus on divining disasters and the attempt to associate meaning tied to circumstances that lead to disruption, disorientation, and displacement is timely. Research into disasters continues to grow but a significant gap remains in connecting the potential of ancient cases studies and past experiences with catastrophe to scholarship concerned with contemporary events. Van Veldhuizen situates his research within the context of disaster studies in the social sciences and his vast use of case studies, from careful reading of ancient Greek texts to The Poseidon Adventure and the account of Saverio Scofani, mark the applicability of his argument beyond Greek civilization. The idea of signs of disasters and disasters as signs is applicable to any society across any period and should position this book as a key text contributing to wider consideration of disasters and the mechanisms used for coping and recovery in their aftermath.

If there is one place where the theoretical foundation could be expanded, it is in the notion of disasters as socially-constructed phenomena. This is something that Van Veldhuizen articulates in the introductory chapter and in other parts of the book. Yet, the notion that institutions, legal structures, infrastructure, political organization, urban planning, etc. can exacerbate the outcome of a disaster is an important keystone of modern disaster research. Anthony Oliver-Smith presented this idea in his book The Martyred City: Death and Rebirth in the Andes (1986) and the disproportionate impacts of disasters on certain segments of the population (e.g., the poor) are now widely recognized. This speaks to the notion of disasters as signs as these different impacted groups will negotiate the aftermath of these disruptions both in trying to understand what happened and why and in trying to construct an explanatory narrative behind this.

The above, however, in no way undermines the arguments and vast amounts of information presented by Van Veldhuizen. The research throughout this book is thorough and the evidence described is clear, well-chosen, and critical in building up a comprehensive thesis and understanding. This is a fascinating book to read and one that can be highly recommended.