BMCR 2026.11.21

Hazard and disaster risk in Ostia: between hypothesis and reality

, , , , Hazard and disaster risk in Ostia: between hypothesis and reality. BAR international series, 3210. Oxford: BAR Publishing, 2025. Pp. vi, 276. ISBN 9781407362069.

[Authors and titles are listed at the end of the review]

 

Hazard and Disaster Risk in Ostia: Between Hypothesis and Reality explores environmental impacts on human settlement, using Ostia as a primary case study—among other comparative ancient Roman sites. As stated in the Introduction, this exploration serves partly to understand the past reactions to or prevention of disasters, and partly in order to learn from the past via ancient responses. Many contributions consider seismic activity and flooding at Ostia against evident human adaptation, both responsive and prophylactic, to these dangers.

The volume derives from a June 2022 conference hosted at the Ostia Antica Archaeological Park, which is available on their YouTube channel. The monograph begins with an introduction, which couches the larger work of the conference and this resulting publication within the study of hazard and disaster. The introductory chapters make the case that examining disaster, disaster risk reduction, and disaster risk management can illuminate past patterns of human resiliency which can be useful examples and tools today in the face of human-induced climate change and other natural calamities. The next three sections are devoted to Ostia: section 2 looks at Ostia and earthquakes generally, section 3 at earthquake impacts on individual structures at Ostia, and section 4 at the immediate environs of Ostia, which are impacted not just by earthquakes, but also by other natural and human-induced disasters such as flooding, plague, and invasion.

The fifth section broadens out to select Roman places including Portus, Rome, and Pompeii and Herculaneum. A section on the anthropology of disasters includes one chapter, before the concluding seventh section’s brief wrap up presented in both English and Italian. In his conclusion, D’Alessio underscores the interdisciplinarity of this endeavor and encourages future work to systematically map and analyze seismic impacts at Ostia. Finally, the text ends with a compact glossary, credited to Laura Pecchioli.

Each chapter has an abstract in both English and Italian. Thirteen chapters are in English, one in Spanish, and twelve in Italian (ten of which have English titles). Generally, contributions are short and accessible. The volume is richly illustrated with maps, plans, and architectural images.

Chapters in the first four sections paint a fascinating picture of disaster studies at Ostia from settlement- and territory-wide syntheses to building-focused analysis on structures. For instance, Johannes Trockels’s study of the so-called Capitolium illustrates examples of ancient cracking—likely from seismic activity—and corresponding repairs to stabilize the building , while the chapter on the Case a Giardino (Ingrid Adenstedt, Stella Falzone, and Peter Ruggendorfer) similarly tracks modifications to the structures in response to earthquake damage. In addition to their engagement with hazard and disaster, the chapters by Holmes, Marina Döring-Williams and Luise Albrecht, and L. Michael White provide nice background to ancient Roman sport, the collapse of Rome’s Basilica of Maxentius, and reinvestigations of Ostia’s synagogue respectively; these crucial summaries are useful to non-specialists and perhaps even students of the ancient Mediterranean world.

Even when promising, some chapters do not always deliver. The validity of rubble from the Neronian fire at Rome used as landfill at Ostia raising the area’s groundwater level (Patrizio Pensabene) is somewhat questionable since the evidence of such an occurrence is fugitive; this argument might be better supported by archaeological or environmental evidence which corroborates such a deposition. Though perhaps a welcome addition to the cultural and touristic offerings at Ostia, it is not clear how the ‘Via Severiana’ project (Marina Marcelli and Fabio Pacciani) fits into this volume. Indeed, one also wonders about the organization of some of the text’s sections, e.g., Holmes’s chapter and the chapter by Benmejo Meléndez, et al. would both perhaps topically fit better into section 4, “The ‘Ostiense’ Territory”. Other inconsistencies (e.g., reference in the Introduction to a chapter about tsunamigenic evidence in southern coastal Spain, which does not appear in the volume) suggest that the monograph suffers from a lack of rigorous editing and standardization.

This volume fits well within the trend of environmental and ecological examination of the ancient Mediterranean, initiated (or in some ways revitalized) by Peregrine Horden and Nicholas Purcell’s The Corrupting Sea: A Study of Mediterranean History (2000; Wiley-Blackwell). Additionally, the text would be in good company with other Ostia-centric works, such as recent publications by the late Simon Keay and his team, Hans Kamermans and L. Bourke Van der Meer’s Designating Place: Archaeological Perspectives on Built Environments in Ostia and Pompeii (2020; Leiden), or Mark Locicero’s Liquid Footprints: Water, Urbanism, and Sustainability in Roman Ostia (2020; Leiden). In combination with these, or in isolation, Hazard and Disaster Risk in Ostia provides a venue for thinking about ancient Roman responses to environmental issues—which can duly inform modern solutions as well.

 

Authors and titles

1 Introduction

1.1 Introduction by Alessandro D’Alessio, David A. Holmes, Roberto Meneghini, Laura Pecchioli

1.2 Hazards vs. Disasters and their implications. The value of pre-and post-event learning for disaster resilience by Laura Pecchioli

2. Ostia and Earthquakes

2.1 Interpretative hypotheses of structural interventions on seismic damage in Ostia Antica by Cairoli Fulvio Giuliani

2.2 Readability of Ostiense disruptions and construction measures by Enrico Rinaldi

2.3 Evidence of seismic damage in Ostia Antica. A résumé of the first structural studies by Laura Pecchioli, Giovanni Cangi

2.4 Historical faulting as the possible cause of earthquake damage in the ancient Roman port city of Ostia by Giuliano Milana, Fabrizio Cara, Daniela Famiani, Alessia Mercuri

2.5 The Role of Sport in Ancient Rome During Periods of Adversity and its Implications for Ostia and Portus by David A. Holmes

2.6 Earthquake in late antique Ostia? For a problematic approach by Carlo Pavolini

3. Seismic Effects on Selected Monuments in Ostia

3.1 Nonlinear dynamic analyses for quantitative measure of historical earthquakes in Ostia. The Piccolo Mercato as a case study by Laura Pecchioli, Michele Betti, Barbara Pintucchi

3.2 Ostia’s so-called Capitolium – A source on construction technology, seismic effects and damage by catastrophes by Johannes Trockels

3.3 The case study of the Case a Giardino in Ostia: damage and ancient restoration due to seismic activity? by Ingrid Adenstedt, Stella Falzone, Peter Ruggendorfer

3.4 Terrae motu conlapsum. Earthquake Evidence from the Ostia Synagogue by L. Michael White

3.5 From Shop to Marble deposit: Dating evidence for catastrophic events and changes of function of a Forum-Taberna revisited by the Ostia-Forum-Project (OFP 2011-2015) by Axel Gering, Niccolò Daviddi

4. The ‘Ostiense’ Territory

4.1 The Neronian fire, the Ostiense ponds and the raising of the new Trajan-Adrian quarters by Patrizio Pensabene

4.2 The ‘Via Severiana’ project for the valorization of the historical and environmental context of the Castel Fusano pine forest by Marina Marcelli, Fabio Pacciani

4.3 Natural risks in the suburb of Ostia in Roman and post-Roman age: water hazards and earthquakes by Simona Pannuzi, Carlo Rosa

4.4 Isola Sacra Necropolis (excavations 1988/89): evidence of the Antonine Plague? by Paola Olivanti, Marcello Spanu

4.5 “Vandalica rabies”: some considerations on the disasters attributed to the barbarian invasions on the basis of the archaeological records from Isola Sacra and Portus by Cristina Genovese, Marina Lo Blundo, Emanuela Spagnoli

4.6 Did Ostia tremble in the Middle Ages? Review of a hypothesis on the collapse of the Christian Basilica at Pianabella by Dario Daffara, Stefano Coccia, Fabrizio Galadini

5. Rome, Pompeii, Herculane, Iberian Peninsula

5.1 After the Earthquake. The Ruins of the Basilica of Maxentius in Late Antiquity by Marina Döring-Williams, Luise Albrecht

5.2 L’Insula Occidentalis di Pompeii: passato e presente by Valeria Amoretti, Vincenzo Calvanese, Paolo Mighetto, Antonino Russo, Alessandro Russo, Gabriel Zuchtriegel

5.3 Memoria degli uomini e delle cose. The eruption of Vesuvius from the perspective of ancient Herculaneum by Francesco Sirano

5.4 Investigaciones en el muelle este-oeste de Portus, resultados e interpretaciones by Javier Bermejo Meléndez, Juan M. Campos Carrasco, Renato Sebastiani

6. Anthropology of Disasters

6.1 Memories of Natural Disasters in Oral Societies by Patrick D. Nunn

7. Conclusions

7.1 Concluding remarks by Alessandro D’Alessio

7.2 Considerazioni conclusive e programmatiche by Alessandro D’Alessio

8. Glossary by Laura Pecchioli