BMCR 2026.11.17

Living in a world of change: new perspectives on cultural exchange and transfer in the Hellenistic Mediterranean

, , Living in a world of change: new perspectives on cultural exchange and transfer in the Hellenistic Mediterranean. Material appropriation processes in antiquity, 2. Wiesbaden: Reichert Verlag, 2025. Pp. 259. ISBN 9783752007855.

[Authors and titles are listed at the end of the review]

 

The chapters of this edited volume approach a wide range of material evidence from the Hellenistic Mediterranean from diverse theoretical perspectives. The arguments as a whole highlight the varied ways that archaeological material can be approached and how material culture can and should be reanalyzed to answer new questions about the past. Part of the Material Appropriation Processes In Antiquity series, this volume focuses on “art, architecture, inscriptions, and objects of consumption” within various contexts. Editors Francesca Diosono and Dominik Maschek use the introduction to address briefly the methodological plurality by which archaeological evidence has been analyzed in the past decades, with a focus on the “processes of cultural formation” of the late Hellenistic period (9). Asking big questions concerning “the positive qualities and effects of cultural exchange with disruptive factors such as violence, dominance, and subjugation” (9), the editors explore these changes through three sections which treat the issues of “Trade, Exchange, and Mobility,” “Society, Politics, and Power,” and “Religion, Beliefs, and Identity.”

The first section, “Trade, Exchange, and Mobility,” includes three chapters, spanning Delos, Kvarner (Croatia), and Samnium. Diosono’s chapter on Italian traders in the Hellenistic Mediterranean provides an overview of (primarily) inscriptional evidence of Italians in market spaces. However, while attention is paid to the geographical breadth of this evidence, the depth of analysis is uneven, with significantly more attention paid to Delos and the Italian Peninsula.[1] Ana Konestra and Marina Ugarković (chapter 2) analyze the fineware of the Kvarner Gulf and posit that local agency had a visible effect on the trade networks beyond this region. Such an effect includes a trade route connecting to Northern Italy which may have reduced the influence of Greek colonies in Dalmatia, leading to different assemblage patterns. Claudia Widow (chapter 3) presents an analysis of Samnite self-presentation within and outside of Samnium, giving voice to a group often discussed from the Roman point of view (Livy, Strabo, etc.). Using color images of temple ruins, bronze tablet and stone inscriptions, and reconstructions of fragmentary evidence, Widow achieves a nuanced description of Samnite self-presentation, before posing new questions in the conclusion, including why Samnites (and Umbrians, Bruttians, Latins, Sabinians, and Lucanians) abandoned domestic identities abroad and what impact that had on Samnian-Roman conflicts (92).

Section two, “Society, Politics, and Power,” addresses the development of particular regions over time and in reaction to socio-political change. Fabio Saccoccio, Giampaolo Rizzetto, Dario Monti, and Enrico Caruso (chapter 4) introduce material culture, literary, anthropological, and isotopic approaches for the analysis of the cultural homogenization of the Verona District under Roman influence. This wide-ranging piece includes a significant amount of evidence, including funerary inscriptions, grave goods, quotations from Roman authors, comparative geographic survey data, and isotopic analyses of diet. The authors conclude that over time the Cenomanic groups’ identity was influenced by the Veneti and the Romans until their distinctive qualities disappeared in the first century BCE. Given the amount of evidence introduced, the case study of Verona could have benefitted from deeper analysis to explain the interconnections and implications of the poorer quality of Cenomanic evidence in comparison with other regions. Dries Daems (chapter 5) presents a theory-forward look at the complex systems which lead to urban development and how push-pull between polis and Hellenistic Kingdom led to socio-political and economic change in Lydia, Pisidia, Pamphylia, and Sagalassos. While Daems does an admirable job of distilling complex theories into concise summaries, the density of the theory section somewhat limits its accessibility to a reader less familiar with the field. Barbara Sielhorst (chapter 8) analyzes verism versus idealism of the nude portrait within the intentional visual storytelling and visual literacy of Roman statuary. Concluding that nude portraits were “a convincing visualization of a model Roman male in all his complexities” (186), this chapter is well-analyzed and contextualizes the differences between Roman nudes and their Greek precedents in the final two centuries of the Republic.

One of the strongest offerings in the volume is Raffaella De Vela’s colorfully named “The Spider’s Strategies” (chapter 6). This chapter highlights the continuation of local, community networks “despite the constant changes in the global infrastructural and economic system” (150), without denying the impact of Rome on the broader environment. In terms of the volume’s desire to engage with cultural exchange among disruption, De Vela’s analogy of the spider’s web to show how networks have “plastic adaptation able to guarantee their integrity” (149), based on archaeological, epigraphical, and material data-sets from three time periods, brings to life the resiliency of Etrurian identity throughout the Hellenistic period.

A second strong offering comes from Dominik Maschek (chapter 7), who argues that socio-cultural “code-switching” (identified in the introduction as a key theoretical model for this period) does not capture the realities of the violence in Late Republican Italy. Rather Maschek effectively centers the short- and long-term effects of violence on material culture and expressions of discontinuity in the wake of Roman conquest. Maschek’s analysis highlights the long-lasting cultural, organizational, and economic changes in Italy during this period without allowing the reader to lose sight of the process of brutal domination perpetrated by Rome in this period.

Section three, “Religion, Beliefs, and Identity,” closes out the volume with four chapters covering a range of topics. Filippo Coarelli (chapter 9) contributes a short note on a possible Roman copy of a Hellenistic relief, highlighting the need for collections at small museums to be analyzed as part of wider conversations. Manuel Moreno-Alcaide and Tamara Peñalver Carroscosa (chapter 10) take on an analysis of dwellings in Iberian communities as they relate to expressions of identity for their inhabitants. They develop an application of “symbiosis” between different groups and how houses can be loci to understand “being Roman versus appearing Roman” (215). Imitatio of the Roman modus vivendi was not uniform, but rather responded to each individuals’ perception of how to express their own identity within the new Roman imperial administrative system. For example, wealthy Greeks from Ampurias maintained more differentiation from Roman standards in their households, retaining ritual spaces and activities, but including new room types of the Roman style (i.e. atria). Luca Ricci (chapter 11) analyzes “architecture as message” at the sanctuary of Aesculapius at Fregellae. Ricci focuses not on the function of the Asklepeion, but rather how identity (and “unfamiliarity”) can be asserted through architectural decision-making, such as with the Fregellan portico which combines unusual Doric and Ionic elements (and well before the stoa in the Agora at Priene) for an intentional “local result” (228). Sarah Scoppie (chapter 12) closes the volume with an analysis of rural Lomellia mortuary practices. Discussing the utility of using multiple theories, including “code-switching,” social habitus, and other models, in conjunction with one another, Scoppie shows how finds from incomplete contexts can be analyzed and add productively to on-going conversations (such as gender and status). This conjunction lends agency to objects (such as pottery assemblages which can reflect dietary, ritual, gender, and religio-temporal meanings), allowing them to “speak” in various roles.

Unlike many edited volumes that have tackled questions of cultural exchange, identity, and regional specificity, this volume is not bounded by a single theoretical model.[2] Rather chapters engage at their own discretion with varied ways to approach evidence—from Romanization and acculturation to “theory of friction” and “code switching.” However, not all the authors apply terminology in the same way or to the same degree, which can lead to some difficulties in reading across chapters, especially for a novice reader. For example, “Romanisation” appears in the chapters of Maschek (chapter 7) and Moreno-Alcaide and Peñalver Carroscosa (chapter 10), but with much different effect. Both chapters speak to the changing academic conversations around the term, but in such different ways that a novice reader might be left with a bifurcated view that Romanisation is either “collective action” (158) or “assimilation” (203), both, or neither. Two other chapters engage with analyses of pottery remains – chapter 2 by Ana Konestra and Marina Ugarković and chapter 12 by Sarah Scoppie. Konestra and Ugarković embed the theoretical models in their analysis, referring readers to outside source material for definitions and overview. Scoppie overtly defines her theoretical modelling and its application. Both are legitimate strategies (and all the authors named above admirably deal with complex theoretical topics), but they require different engagement from readers. Moreover, given that multiple chapters touch on similar theoretical models, a section devoted to reading across datasets and responding to theoretical applications would have added to the volume.

Each chapter adds to the on-going conversations in each subfield, but readers are likely to be drawn to one or two of the offerings, rather than consuming it cover to cover. At times, some chapters feel as though they would have benefitted from deeper analysis of the evidence and arguments presented; for example, in the first chapter, Diosono presents a fascinating peak into the implications of bilingualism in multi-cultural spaces, but does not discuss the impact of how the “behavior and abilities of these bilingual traders would have differed significantly” from their monolingual counterparts (19). Additionally, Coarelli’s chapter provides a detailed description of a Hellenistic relief, but its conclusions rely heavily on supposition. Readers would benefit from a more thorough analysis of possible comparanda for cultic movement and buildings in the Near East. But, considering the total volume length of only 259 pages, each chapter is well-supported with color images, maps, and figures. Overall, this is an interesting survey of archaeological and literary datasets and the methods by which they can be exploited to develop our understanding of the Hellenistic Mediterranean world.

 

Authors and Titles

Francesca Diosono and Dominik Maschek. “The Archaeology of Late Hellenistic Rome, Italy, and the Wider Mediterranean: Value Systems, Social Hegemony, and Material Culture”

 

Section 1

Francesca Diosono. “In the Name of Gods and the Market. Organisation and Self-Definition of Italian Traders in the Hellenistic Mediterranean”

Ana Konestra and Marina Ugarković. “To Each Their Own: Fine Wares, Appropriation and Changing Social Practices of the Last Centuries B.C. in the Kvarner (NE Adriatic, Croatia)”

Claudia Widow. “Samnites Just in Samnium?! Epigraphic Self-Presentation of Samnite Elite Members in Religious Contexts at Home and Abroad”

 

Section 2

Fabio Saccoccio, Giampaolo Rizzetto, Dario Monti, Enrico Caruso. “The Verona District (Veneto, NE Italy) in the Later Iron Age: Cenomanic Gauls between the Atestine World and Roman Power”

Dries Daems. “Between cities and kings. Polis formation in Southwest Anatolia during the Hellenistic period”

Raffaella Da Vela. “The Spider’s Strategies. Social Networks as Resilience Strategies in Hellenistic Northern Etruria”

Dominik Maschek. “Violence and Cultural Change in Late Republican Italy”

Barbara Sielhorst. “Beyond Idealism and Realism: How to Evaluate Nude Portrait Statues in Late Republican Central Italy”

 

Section 3

Filippo Coarelli. “A late Hellenistic relief at Basel and the cult of Tellus”

Manuel Moreno-Alcaide and Tamara Peñalver. “Carrascosa Dwellings in transition: ‘to be Roman’ in Iberian communities”

Luca Ricci. “The sanctuary of Aesculapius at Fregellae: local decisions and semantic systems in the Mediterranean oikoumene”

Sarah Scoppie. “Switching to Roman? Translating and understanding identity in Late Iron Age mortuary contexts from the Lomellina”

 

Notes

[1] I would be remiss if I did not mention the factual error in this chapter. Diosono states that in Delos “The epigraphic evidence that has come down to us only includes Greek and Latin…” (21). Foreigners on Delos used a variety of languages, including Aramaic (ID 2315) and Minean (RES 3952; M 349), often in bilingual inscriptions alongside Greek. Italians were not unique in using their primary language (Latin) in parallel with Greek.

[2] For example, Anna Kouremenos and Jody Gordon, Mediterranean archaeologies of insularity in an age of globalization (Oxford: Oxbow Books, 2020) and Jeremy Tanner and Andrew Gardner, Materialising the Roman Empire (London: UCL Press, 2024), engaging questions of globalization and imperialism, respectively.