Bryn Mawr Classical Review

Bryn Mawr Classical Review 1998.3.20


Reviewed by
Word count: words

RESPONSE: Bartlett on Bolin on Bartlett

Dear Editor,

I have received from Routledge a print-out of your review ofArchaeology and Biblical Interpretation (Routledge, 1997, reviewedatBMCR 97.12.6),and though I do not usually respond to reviewers, I feel that I must respondon this occasion. I was astonished at the views credited to me in it. Igrant that the inexplicable reference to Helena's status is shocking; itis always a mistake to edit one's own work. It is true that the classicallyeducated would have known about Egypt and Mesopotamia from Herodotus, Strabo,Xenophon and others, but I think it is also true that the great majorityof people until the nineteenth century would have known of these places,as I wrote, primarily from their bibles.

However, in what follows I simply do not recognise myself. I most certainlydo not seek to limit archaeology to the ancillary role of clarifying ourunderstanding of biblical texts, and there is nothing in my chapter whichsuggests that I do. I do not see the archaeological material as subordinateto the biblical -- I make that abundantly clear on p. 13. I do notsubscribeto the circular argumentation of the Albright school, and I point to thescholarly criticism of it on pp. 7-8, 11. I have no 'desire to neutralizearchaeology from any real challenges to the Bible's historical truth', asmust be clear from pp. 10-11. I agree entirely that archaeology can provideevidence which challenges or demands the revision of certain biblical historicalor theological claims -- I actually quote on page 11 his example of thearchaeologicalevidence for the extent of David and Solomon's power. Any scholar readingpages 10-14 of my chapter will see that they are directed precisely againstthe views with which I appear to be credited with in Bolin's review article.

In sum, your critique totally misrepresents me, and I can only concludethat he simply has not read my chapter, especially pages 10-14, with dueattention. I find this much more shocking than the unfortunate slip aboutHelena.

Yours sincerely,

Prof. John R. Bartlett

Read Latest
Index for 1998
Change Greek Display
Books Available for Review

HTML generated at 13:26:04, Friday, 03 April 2009